Residents voice concern over Harvard plan
In a meeting with town residents Monday night, Harvard officials fielded questions about the center to be built on Barry's Corner - a keystone project of the university's 20-year "Institutional Master Plan" to move across the Charles River to an Allston neighborhood where several athletic facilities and administrative buildings already exist.
Allston residents have voiced concern about Harvard's encroachment upon already-developed land.
"I signed on to this deal to become partners with Harvard," said Allston resident Tim McHale at Monday's meeting. "Now, I'm beginning to doubt that partnership."
McHale said his excitement about the benefits the Art Center could bring to Allston was diminished by Harvard's unilateral decision-making.
"It is time Harvard reestablished its relationship with this community and reasserted itself as a partner rather than a single-minded entity," he said.
Boston City Council ripped for debating Iraq resolution
City councilors led by Chuck Turner spent 48 minutes yesterday debating a symbolic measure calling for the withdrawal of troops from Iraq as Boston neighborhoods face deadly violence exploding outside their homes daily.
Other councilors, including Sal LaMattina, Stephen Murphy and Jerry McDermott, argued they are paid $87,500 a year by their constituents to discuss Boston issues, not foreign policy. McDermott, who represents the Allston/Brighton area, added that if the war in Iraq is open to discussion on the City Council floor, so should “securing our borders” and skyrocketing prison costs.
Where is the "planning" in Harvard Planning?
We know Harvard has lots of money, but before spending hundreds of millions of dollars on a new building doesn’t Harvard review all possible locations and choose the best one?
Hope has two children: anger and courage
- Christian theologian St. Augustine of Hippo (Aurelius Augustinus, 354-430)
Harvard and the Community circa 1969
This is an interesting article to get some historical perspective about Harvard interacting with the community almost 40 years ago. Here are two excerpts:
"Three weeks later, as the April crisis hit Harvard, a widespread debate over University-community relations finally occurred. Through "University expansion," as it came to be called, was much less discussed than ROTC, and much of the discussion of community issues was confused and rhetoric laden, it nevertheless was the first time in memory, and probably in the history of the University, that any substantial number of people had stopped to give any thought whatsoever to the relationship between Harvard and the communities which surround her."
"The last year has seen a change in University attitudes toward the surrounding communities--a switch from an aloof posture to be emphasizing an active involvement to aid Cambridge and Boston. But the change is not necessarily definitive; it could be reversed if the problems created by the new position seem to be greater than those arising in the past. Only time will tell if the various segments, of the University-including the Corporation, faculty, and students alike--will retain their new-found enthusiasm for aiding the community."
City braces for a one-day school strike
After 13 months of negotiations, Boston teachers appear ready to hold a one-day strike on Thursday for the first time in 14 years, forcing city and school officials to draw up contingency plans for the system's roughly 58,000 students with no school to attend.
Officials Face Concerns Over Allston Expansion
Harvard Crimson story about last night's Harvard Allston Task Force meeting
Brighton Commercial Corridor Project Charette
The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes…But in having new eyes….
Brighton Main Streets invites you to attend our Brighton Commercial Corridor Project Charette on Saturday, March 3, 2007 from 8:30 am to 1:00pm at St. Elizabeth’s Medical Center ~ Seton Auditorium.
Brighton Main Streets commissioned a conceptual urban design plan in 2002. One major aspect of this plan was to create a visually unified series of corridors leading throughout the Brighton neighborhood commercial district. On Saturday, March 3rd our design committee will begin this process by means of open dialogue and creative visualization. We need your ideas and input. Please plan on joining us…bring your community “wish list”, your ideas and of course your “new eyes”. A light breakfast and lunch will be served. For more information and to register for the Charrette, please contact Rosie Hanlon, Executive Director, Brighton Main Streets at 617-779-9200 or email at rosie@brightonmainstreets.org
Zoning Board of Appeals Hearings on Feb. 27
Hearings are at 11:30 on Tuesday, February 27.
- 24 Farrington Avenue - Extend living space into the basement of a three-family dwelling
- 116 Lake Street - Confirm the legal occupancy as a one-family dwelling and extend
living space into the basement - 578-580 Washington Street - Change the legal occupancy from a real estate office and three apartments to three apartments and body art establishment
Board of Appeal
1010 Massachusetts Avenue, 4th floor
Boston, MA 02118
Please feel free to call the Board of Appeal at 617-635-4775 if there is a question or concern you might have regarding this matter.
How Harvard Responded to the Harvard Allston Task Force
Remarks by President-Elect Drew Gilpin Faust
"...We are beginning an expansion into Allston that will provide the space in which to make new connections - among scientific disciplines, between teaching and scientific research, among professional schools, between the community and the University. At the same time, it offers us the ability to improve significantly the facilities for graduate and undergraduate students, for the arts and for athletics....
What Harvard does in this next decade will serve as an important part of the answer to these contradictions and challenges. What we do will determine not only whether Harvard retains its preeminence. It will help to define the character and meaning of universities for the 21st century - whether they can be supple enough, enterprising enough, ambitious enough to accomplish all that is expected of them..."
Faust points Harvard forward - Boston Globe Editorial
"She pointed to Harvard's plans to build a new campus in Allston. Now Faust must turn what has been a rocky courtship into a happy marriage. Early sketches show a campus that could be Parisian in its elegance. But it should also fit in with the scale and soul of Allston."
Harvard Prof To Design City?
"Recent media speculation surrounding Professor in Practice of Urban Design Alex Krieger’s placement on a long list of candidates to lead the Boston Redevelopment Authority (BRA) has people on both sides of the river concerned about the University’s role in Allston development..."
City builds long list of candidates for BRA job
"Harvard urban planning guru Alex Krieger has long been one of City Hall’s favorite architects.
Now Krieger is being talked about by insiders as a top candidate to head the city’s most powerful agency, the Boston Redevelopment Authority. "
Will Harvard's new president confront the truth about Harvard's community relations?
Harvard expansion at the Arnold Arboretum
Roslindale Wetlands Task Force
The Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University has proposed building a 45,000-square-foot institutional facility on land it owns near the Roslindale Wetlands.A public meeting about the proposal is scheduled for Wednesday, January 31, 6:30 p.m., at St. Nectarios Greek Orthodox Church in Roslindale Square. All concerned about this project or interested in learning more are encouraged to attend.
The most prominent concern voiced by neighbors to date was the lack of permanent preservation of green space at the site. The Boston Redevelopment Authority has already received a heavy volume of comments about the proposal—proof that comments from the public are noticed and DO make a difference.
Welcome, Harvard; now be a good neighbor - The Boston Globe
"NORTH ALLSTON/NORTH BRIGHTON is a thriving Boston neighborhood bounded by the Mass. Pike and the Charles River, a place where new families settle and long time homeowners maintain tidy yards. Home to 10,000 people of many cultures, this neighborhood stands poised between imminent danger and unprecedented opportunity. For in the past decade, Harvard University has bought hundreds of acres of our neighborhood, and later this year Harvard hopes to start construction of its massive new Allston campus--more than 4 million square feet of new development to be built in the next 20 years..."
Harvard Selects New President
"Drew Gilpin Faust, a Civil War scholar, will tackle a “reconstruction” of her own as the new president of Harvard—bringing the University back together after the tumultuous tenure of Lawrence H. Summers."
Harvard to Cambridge - You are still our #1
The Harvard Crimson :: News :: Harvard Talks Up New Housing
At the annual Cambridge Town-Gown meeting, Harvard assured Cambridge that despite the slew of construction across the river in Allston, “Cambridge remains the heart of the University.”
Also, there was significant discussion about the advantages for Cambridge as Harvard plans to move undergrads to Allston to make room for more grad student housing in Cambridge. Grad students certainly will do more for the local economy as opposed to undergrads whose experience is more insular to their colllege. Grad students are more likely to have children and to be part of the community.
In Harvard's 50 year "plan" for Allston there are just a few new housing buildings proposed that would seem to be likely to contribute to the North Allston/North Brighton community.
By the numbers, in the next 50 years Harvard proposes 1.2 million sq ft of undergrad dorms in Allston. That is more than 3 times the amount of grad student housing proposed for Allston (350,000 sq ft).
New Harvard Art Museum, Concerns - The Boston Globe
The Globe picked up Jeff Bryan's recent letter about Harvard's proposal for an Art Warehouse on Western Ave.
In Defense of One Western Avenue
George Thrush is director of the School of Architecture at Northeastern University. Here are a couple excerpts from his article about why 1 Western Ave is not so bad.
Let’s face it. The graduate student dormitory at the Harvard along the Charles River, known as One Western Avenue, is an almost uniquely reviled building. Since its completion a few years ago, it has been pilloried by neighbors, activists, critics, and even architects.
The building has no doubt failed to perform a key political act, namely securing a modern future for the new Harvard in Allston. And the building’s negative press has since fed on itself to the point that One Western Avenue is now seen as a serious cautionary (and very negative) example of how things might go wrong in the high stakes world of Harvard’s institutional planning for its expansion.
Award Winning Campus Designs
Here's a REAL master plan to create a cultural mecca
Celebrity Architects Reveal a Daring Cultural Xanadu for the Arab World
The designs presented here in Abu Dhabi, the capital of the United Arab Emirates and one of the world’s top oil producers, are to be built on an island just off the coast and include three museums designed by the celebrity architects Frank Gehry, Jean Nouvel and Tadao Ando, as well as a sprawling, spaceshiplike performing arts center designed by Zaha Hadid.
Mr. Gehry’s building is intended for an Adu Dhabi branch of the Guggenheim Museum featuring contemporary art and Mr. Nouvel’s for a classical museum, possibly an outpost of the Louvre Museum in Paris. Mr. Ando’s is to house a maritime museum reflecting the history of the Arabian gulf.
The project also calls for a national museum and a biennial exhibition space composed of 19 pavilions designed by smaller names and snaking along a canal that cuts through the island. Art schools and an art college are also planned.
An idea from New York that could make our neighbhorhood more livable and walkable
“The City That Never Walks,” by Robert Sullivan (Op-Ed, Jan. 29), is right. New York City must change its priorities and reapportion its precious public real estate, too much of which has been given over to the motor vehicle.
New York City should simply convert approximately every 10th street to a green street, with widened sidewalks, bike paths and clean bus rapid transit lines. Other vehicles would be permitted to enter these green streets for a single block for loading and unloading only.
This simple, elegant step would bring New York into the 21st century, and prepare it for a growing population with efficient and environmental transportation, while building on the city’s true and rich character as a pedestrian city.
Gary Eckstein - Brooklyn, Jan. 29, 2007
Other neighborhoods across Boston wait for new branch libraries
This story is a reminder of how fortunate we are to have the Honan Allston Library in our neighborhood. Across the city other residents look at our library as a model for what they would like to see where they live.
Harvard's Allston expansion plan turning a corner? - The Boston Globe
This story in today's Globe discusses the future of Barry's Corner. The story does get into the details of the "art warehouse" that Harvard wants to build in Barry's Corner or how Harvard wants to move private athletic facilities (pool, hockey rink, basketball court) into Barry's Corner to make room for dormitories along the river.
Maybe you will agree with me that this story merits a Letter to the Editor to explain how, despite Harvard's PR spin, there seems to be little real interest in making the great Barry's Corner that could one day exist. Here is the letter I submitted:
Harvard is not creating the ‘hub of activity’ at Barry's Corner in Allston that it would lead you to believe (“Harvard's Allston Expansion Plan Turning a Corner” - February 3). In fact, Harvard’s only planned Barry's Corner project would do just the opposite. This ‘art warehouse’ falls far short of the great public museum that Harvard could create and that Allston would welcome. Harvard has proposed a building that will mostly be used for office and storage space, and art would be displayed in less than 10% of the building. Barry’s Corner needs vibrant public buildings to become a world-class public space. But instead of ambitious projects to make the most of Allston’s wonderful potential, Harvard is creating a widening gulf between an attractive long-term vision and the disappointing reality of what Harvard plans to build.
Is Harvard Really Doing It Right with Its Neighbors?
It is always interesting to see another perspective! Ed Kent write from New York after reading Harvard's press release about the wonderful community engagment that Harvard describes as happening in Allston. (I'm not sure I know anyone who lives in Allston who would describe it that way.) Ed also write about what is happening with Columbia University as it plans to expand into Manhattanville. Sounds so much worse that what is happening here in Allston and Brighton, as locals there fear taking of property by eminent domain.
Allston eateries' snacks emit international flavor - The Boston Globe
Allston restaurants mentioned include: Soul Fire Barbecue, Hanmaru, Infusions Tea Spa, Aneka Rasa, Color, Madina Market's Kitchen, Moscow International Food Store, and Camino Real.
University of Pennsylvania Master Plan
New City Council Committee Assignments
Allston Master Plan Met with Frustration
Tempers flared and questions remained unanswered at a fiery meeting of Allston residents and Harvard officials last Wednesday.
The meeting marked the first discussion with Allston residents since the University released a robust 50-year plan earlier this month for its fledgling campus across the Charles River.
Allston resident Matthew Snyder expressed frustration with the University’s response.
“I come to these meetings for answers. And I didn’t get any,” Snyder said.
“I think there’s a huge disconnect between the community of Allston and Harvard,” he added.
Pete Sampras to play tennis in Allston
Pete Sampras, one of the best tennis players in the history of the storied game, will be coming back to play competitive tennis very soon. However, fans won't be seeing him on a court trying to stop Roger Federer from breaking his Grand Slam singles record. Instead, he will be playing in tennis' senior circuit for players over 30.
Sampras let his intentions be known in an interview with AP. He said his first match back will be in the Outback Champions Series tournament scheduled for May 2-6 in Boston at the Boston University Agganis Arena on Comm Ave in Allston.
Allston Village Main Streets annual meeting & networking night
Thursday, February 8
6 - 8 p.m.
The Kells 161 Brighton Ave
Learn about what is happening in Allston Village and meet Mark Hayes, our new police captain. Cash bar & FREE FOOD from Allston Village's newest restaurants.
Hub's grades are in
A new program, Boston About Results, was launched last summer to provide the mayor, and citizens, quantitative measures of how well the city is providing the services it promises. This Globe article looks at the results and publishes the "report cards" for several City departments.
The City That Never Walks
An interesting op-ed piece in today's Times. Brings to mind the many ways that our neighborhood could be more pedestrian and bike friendly on Western Ave, N Harvard, Cambridge St, from our homes to the river, and throughout the area.
Residents seek details of Harvard development plans - The Boston Globe
CSX rail tracks for sale
THE PATRICK administration has been handed a major opportunity to improve the commuter rail network in eastern Massachusetts. The CSX railroad corporation wants to sell its rail lines west to Worcester, south to Fall River and New Bedford, and north to Somerville...
A state takeover would allow the MBTA to expand service by shifting from a one-track to a two-track operation. It would also provide land for construction of a commuter rail station near the proposed Harvard campus in Allston...
But it sounds as if CSX is phasing out its freight service to the rail yards in Allston, and, if that's the case, it will not need rail lines in eastern Massachusetts...
How many new Allston residents & how much new open space?
Harvard's 20 year plan proposed 1.4 million square feet of new housing in North Allston. This is 800,000 sq ft of undergraduate housing, 350,000 sq ft of graduate housing, and 250,000 sq ft of Business School housing.
How many people would live in 1.4 million square feet of housing? Harvard estimates that there will be 590 beds in the 350,000 square feet of graduate housing. That is 600 sq ft per bed. How many people sleep in each bed is another question, but I will assume it is 1 for the sake of this estimating exercise.
1.4 million square feet of housing & 600 sq. ft per person = 2,300 additional Allston residents.
On average, Boston has 7.4 acres of open space per 1,000 residents. (Allston/Brighton is well below that, with 4.8 acres per 1,000.)
If new open space should be created at the same time new residents are added at the 7.4 per 1000 ratio, that means that 17 acres of new open space should be created to accompany the 2,300 new Allston residents that Harvard plans to add.
Harvard's press release that accompanied the 50 year plan announces an intention to "create more than 30 acres of new open space". In the 20 year plan there are 3 acres of open space in Rena Park and an unspecified amount of open space that burying Soldiers Field Road and a Science Courtyard would create.
(The estimates of square footage of housing to be constructed comes from page 16 of The Plan for Harvard in Allston executive summary. The 250,000 sq ft of Business School housing is an estimate based on the 500,000 sq ft mentioned as part of a "Harvard Business School Academic and Housing" line item.)
More information about open space in Allston/Brighton is in the Boston Open Space plan. The Allston/Brighton portion of that plan is here.
Crowds blast Harvard plan at Wednesday meeting
Rivera declines to accept post as Boston school superintendent
Mayor Thomas M. Menino scrambled back to Boston last night from the nation's capital, outraged after a much publicized deal to sign Manuel J. Rivera as school superintendent collapsed without notice.
Is Harvard thinking generously about its plans for Allston?
"If a museum of modern art is built on that site, I hope that Harvard will think big and generously about it. Let the museum have breathing room. When the Fogg was opened in 1895, a blueprint existed that showed how it might one day expand onto the adjoining site, where the Carpenter Center went up instead in 1963. The Fogg has suffered from being hemmed in by the Carpenter Center. I would be terribly disappointed if that happened at the river site. The Sackler and the Busch-Reisinger Museum in Werner Otto Hall are not what they ought to be, and even when new they weren't. Let's not do something typical of so many Harvard projects and make a building that isn't what it ought to be."
http://www.harvardmag.com/nd99/jhj.riverfront.html
Scoping Determination for Harvard Science Complex
- Scoping Determination with Comments, 4 MB file, 164 pages
- Scoping Determination without Comments, 0.2 MB file, 19 pages
Immigrant sentenced in bribery case
Property liens eyed in trash crackdown
City councilors are expected to pass a home-rule petition today to put liens on the properties of those with unpaid trash fines, a move that comes days after the Herald reported Boston has not collected $3.4 million in code violations.
“I like the idea of getting tough on scofflaws and collecting money,” said City Councilor Jerry McDermott, who represents student-heavy Allston-Brighton. “Under the current system, it is too easy for landlords to say if no one is making them pay, why pay?”
Harvard discusses moving Med School researchers to Allston
Several influential department heads at Harvard Medical School are discussing the possibility of moving hundreds of researchers and staff from the Longwood medical area to Harvard's emerging campus in Allston.
The proposal under discussion, though still in very preliminary stages, could shift nearly half of the people now occupying the iconic quadrangle at the heart of the medical school -- up to 70 professors and 500 to 700 staff members -- to a new 1-million-square-feet building in Allston.
Cambridge Town Gown Presentations - Feb 6
Town Gown presentations will take place at the Tuesday February 6 Planning Board meeting which begins at 7:30. The meeting will take place at the Cambridge Citywide Senior Center at 806 Massachusetts Avenue.
For more information contact Cliff Cook, Planning Information Manager, Cambridge Community Development Dept, ccook@cambridgema.gov, 617/349-4656.
The 2006 Cambridge Town Gown reports from Harvard, MIT, and Lesley are online.
Boston's The Weekly Dig: News & Opinions: Bean Counter
"As part of a massive 50 year plan to expand its Allston campus like some matter of smug Crimson tumor, Harvard announces plans to bury part of Soldiers Field Road underground to make way for a riverside park. Working-class JP residents are advised to stay away from it, for at least two reasons. MINUS 1"
Harry Fig's View of Harvard's Plan

Thanks to Peter Wallace for sharing this perspective in today's Boston Globe. Click the image here to see a larger view.
Illegally paved parking spots all over the city
The GlobeWatch column from last Sunday ("Illegal parking lots pockmark Brighton neighborhood," Jan. 14, City Weekly) concerned illegally paved parking lots on residential property in Cleveland Circle. However, this problem is ubiquitous and deserving of far greater attention by the Globe.
Party's over at Pan9, at least for now - The Boston Globe
When fire broke out at an artists complex on Rugg Road in Allston in the early-morning hours of Dec. 29 , the impact was immediate for those who lived and worked there: about 30 people displaced, with several units damaged by fire, smoke, water, and the ax blows of firefighters.
Roughly half are now back in their homes and work spaces, with the remainder waiting to hear when, or even if, they will be allowed back in. The future is even more uncertain for an artistic event and community known as Pan9, centered on the top-floor, five-bedroom space where the fire started.
Harvard 02134 and the challenges it brings to the T
The "Charlie on the MBTA" blog has thoughts on the transportation impact of Harvard's plans for Allston
Apparently Derek Bok Is Doing Something...
richardbradley.net has a long post about Harvard's recently announced plans for Allston. He concludes with:
"Now that I think about it, it seems this conversation needs to broaden. Harvard undergrads, athletes, and alums, as well as Allston residents, need to get involved....
Because Harvard's plan essentially privatizes an entire neighborhood, and to the untrained eye—mine—there are some real questions here."
Making Lincoln Street Safer

It is great to see this speed display unit on Lincoln Street near the intersection with Everett St to help slow down traffic and make the neighborhood safer. Lincoln St has been the scene of numerous accidents over the years, including a bicyclist hit by a car and killed a couple of years ago and various incidents when cars have skidded off the road and hit walls and fences along the side of the road.
It is ironic that this piece of equipment, parked in front of the building Harvard bought last month for $16 million, was donated to the City by Boston University (note the small red letters on the main box of the machine).
Several People Evacuated After Allston Fire
Boston College set to file master plan - Allston/Brighton TAB
"In what will be the second such filing by a major Allston-Brighton institution within a two-month period, Boston College is readying itself to file a 10-year Institutional Master Plan with the BRA."
The BC task force meetings are open to the public and are scheduled for the third Tuesday of every month at the Brighton Marine Health Center, 77 Warren St., Brighton, 6:30 p.m.
Boston College Community Fund - $175,000 for Allston/Brighton
The Allston Brighton/Boston College Community Fund Committee has announced that three additional grants totaling $175,000 will be distributed in February, 2007.
$50,000 Youth Enrichment
$50,000 Beautification
$75,000 Civic Engagement
The deadline for applications is Friday, January 19th (today) by 5:00pm
Fair alcohol license distribution debated at ACA meeting
Wonderful future for neighborhood: Menino’s a visionary for Allston
This is in the "must read" category. It is an interview by Herald Columnist Virginia Buckingham with Mayor Menino about the future of Allston.
Boston University Free Press Editorial: Here comes Harvard
New building projects inevitably scare residents. If it happens in their neighborhood, they are often forced to reconstruct their lives.
So when Harvard University announces a multibillion-dollar, 200-acre plan to build what it hopes to be a sort of Harvard Square 2, it's no wonder many Allston inhabitants are weary.
A project requiring 8,712,000 square feet to create will intrude on residents' space. If the construction doesn't physically knock down their homes, the increased cost of living could be enough to kick much of the population out.
In an area where the median income is $38,941 and 23 percent of residents live in poverty, according to the Allston-Brighton Data Profile, building a high-class shopping area that could become Boston's newest tourist trap won't exactly lower rent prices.
Boston's museums after dark
Related to Harvard's suggestion for art and cultural buildings in Allston, this story is about what other museums in Boston do in the evenings to help make Boston a fun and interesting city.
The MFA is open late on Wednesdays, for free, and on Thursdays and Fridays at regular price. The museum's most popular night is the first Friday of each month, when it holds parties for young professional types. The new Institute of Contemporary Art also has a free night, on Thursdays, and the Museum of Science offers special programs and gourmet dishes on Friday nights. The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum keeps its doors open late for special concerts, like the Feb. 16 "Composer Portraits" program featuring pieces by Conlon Nancarrow.
(The Museum of Fine Arts is open until 9:45 p.m. Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays (free after 4 on Wednesdays). The Museum of Science, including its observatory (weather permitting) is open Fridays until 10 p.m.; its Science Street Cafe is open from 6 to 10 p.m.. The ICA is open Thursdays until 9 p.m. for free.)
Is it time for a Harvard room in Allston?
We all know that Harvard has a lot of empty office space in Allston. Maybe they could convert space in the KMart building into a "Harvard Room" here in Allston. Even if it was open one day a week (how about Thursdays from 2-8pm) it would give many people in Allston a chance to better understand Harvard's plans.
The exhibit could have, among other things, architectural models of the Allston neighborhood and the projects that Harvard has proposed, especially the buildings that Harvard wants to start building this year.
Harvard's Allston Room Open House tomorrow morning
Please attend an Allston Room Open House to learn more about the project from Chris Gordon, Chief Operating Officer and Kathy Spiegelman, Chief Planner, Allston Development Group.
Thursday, January 18, 8:00am - 9:30am
Thursday, January 25, 5:00pm - 6:30pm
Holyoke Arcade
1350 Massachusetts Avenue
University of Oregon Campus Plan
Policy 11: Patterns
This is very interesting document that describes how the University of Oregon approaches growth and change in its campus. The section on "patterns" contains several guidelines that they seek to apply to their projects. These include:
Building Complex
The human scale vanishes in enormous buildings. People who use them stop identifying the staff who work there as personalities, and the staff feel like small cogs in a greater machine.
THEREFORE: To maintain human scale in campus buildings, make them small, perhaps no larger than 100,000 gross square feet (with some notable exceptions such as libraries and recreation facilities) and not more than three or four stories high. If more space is needed, the buildings should be conceived as a collection connected by arcades or bridges defining and embracing outdoor spaces.
Good Neighbor
It’s easy to be so focused on making campus projects as wonderful as possible for their users that we ignore their impacts on our neighbors.
THEREFORE: Consider each project’s impacts on neighbors and community. For example, what will the building look like from outside the campus boundaries? What parking impacts may spill over into other areas?
Four-story Limit
An important aspect of the campus’s beauty is access to sunlight, views of the sky, and human scale.
THEREFORE: Keep the majority of buildings four stories high or less. It is possible that a few buildings may exceed this limit, but strong consideration must be given to the resultant shadows and skyline to ensure the beauty of the campus and the importance of the individual.
Open University
When a university campus is separated from the town by a hard boundary, students and townspeople tend to be isolated from each other; in a subtle way the university takes on the character of a glorified high school.
THEREFORE: Ensure that the campus edges are soft and the gateways marking the boundary between university and town are welcoming and inviting to townspeople rather than shunning. For students, make easy connections to the town so they are encouraged to visit the town often.
Help for Boston's next boom - Boston Globe Editorial
"BOSTON IS on the verge of a building boom without a permanent director of the Boston Redevelopment Authority, the city's planning and development agency. Mayor Menino may be hands-on when it comes to development, but there are more projects in play than he could possibly juggle. And his judgment is anything but flawless in this area.
Massive changes are in store from North Allston, where Harvard University is planning its campus of the future, to East Boston, where luxury housing is being built along the piers. But who will pay for Harvard's proposal to sink a section of Soldiers Field Road and create a tree-lined promenade along the river?...
The next BRA director will soon see that even the simple stuff can be complicated. Suffolk University recently responded to the mayor's call to build dormitories as a means to ease pressure on the housing market in surrounding neighborhoods. But the Suffolk dorm proposal enflamed Beacon Hill residents instead. The BRA downsized the dorm out of respect, and Suffolk complied. Suddenly the mayor wearied of the whole thing and killed the project.
Profile of New York's Chief Planner
“She cares about each building and its details in a way that no other planning director has that I can remember, and I go back a long way,” said Jerold S. Kayden, director of the master’s program in urban planning at the Harvard Graduate School of Design. “She’s wise enough to recognize that what I would call small details or granular moves can either enhance or destroy a city. In a funny way she’s the curator of a living, breathing city.”
Universities should look beyond themselves
Sunil Abraham notes how many universities wall themselves off from the surrounding communities, either literally or figuratively.
Harvard Plans Science, Arts Centers on Boston Campus - Bloomberg.com
``The theme is one of connection,'' Harvard Provost Steven Hyman said at a news conference in Boston. ``We want to use Allston to take us to new levels of excellence.''
Illegal parking lots pockmark Brighton neighborhood - The Boston Globe
After a Brighton resident complains to the Globe about paved front yard parking lots, a code enforcement officer from Boston's Inspectional Services issued citations to 14 homeowners for violating the city's zoning ordinance. During an evening inspection of the same area on Dec. 14, enforcement officers found more than 100 cars parked in illegally enlarged driveways and parking lots. Some vehicles blocked sidewalks or were unregistered and abandoned. They issued 14 citations to these landlords and fined them $150 a piece. Fines jumped to $300 each for last week's round of tickets because it was the second violation for most in the last 12 months.
Harvard unveils its vision of campus across Charles - The Boston Globe
Excerpts from Globe story:
"The compatibility issue is really the main problem," said Ray Mellone, chairman of the Allston community task force on the Harvard expansion, referring to fears that traffic and bustle would invade the neighborhood.
The university will also need approval from the state Department of Conservation and Recreation, which manages the land along the river, and from the state Historical Commission to put Soldier's Field Road underground and for other construction along the Charles River.
Secretary of State William F. Galvin, who chairs the Historical Commission, said the university's plans to submerge the roadway and build a pedestrian bridge over the Charles appear mainly to benefit the university and not members of the community.
"Clearly, the university is treating the river like some moat that they own," Galvin said. "It is not theirs, and it will be protected."
"We're not presuming we can do all this," said Christopher M. Gordon, chief operating officer for Harvard's Allston Development Group, which is managing the expansion. "We want to make sure we work with everybody."
Charlie on the MBTA: Harvard 02134 and the challenges it brings to the T
Thanks to Sophia for mentioning this post about Harvard's expansion plans and the possibilities for expanded public transportation.
The Harvard Crimson :: News :: Harvard Unveils 50-Year Plan For Allston
Harvard Crimson story excerpts:
“It’s definitely different from the norm,” said Gerald Autler, the project manager for the Boston Redevelopment Authority .
Harvard’s chief planner for Allston, Kathy Spiegelman, said the plans would create a “professional school corridor” by relocating the School of Public Health and the Graduate School of Education nearer the existing Business School site.
Harvard’s relationship with residents of Allston, and Charlesview in particular, remains fraught. Occupants protested the building’s board of directors’ decision to cooperate in a land swap with Harvard last November.
But Spiegelman said Harvard believes “there is no reason we can’t improve the quality of life of people who also share the Allston community.”
“[Allston] could be a much more vibrant area,” Christopher M. Gordon, the head of Harvard’s Allston Development Group said, “not just for Harvard by for the community and region.”
The Harvard Crimson :: Opinion :: A President of the Community
Excerpts from an opinion article by Rachel M. Singh, Harvard ’10, a Crimson editorial editor:
The next president should mend our community image and prioritize student interests
Richard Harding, Jr. of the Cambridge Public School Committee has blamed Harvard for doing little to help local poor and under-performing public schools. “I really need to know what the hell are they doing for us,” he said. Ten years after covertly buying land in Allston, Harvard has yet to publicize how its expansion will affect local residents. Community meetings and donations to build a library are no more than an excellent public relations campaign if the University ends up driving out residents.
We must repair our image in our neighborhood and defy stereotypes about the Harvard bubble and its self-interested policies. The integrity of this institution rests not just on tallying up its Nobel Prize count, but also in the fair treatment of its workers and in its social and environmental responsibility to the community.
Similarly, the president must not weigh Harvard’s global prestige before its responsibility to its community, both in and outside its walls.
Harvard unveils Allston plan: Proposal for bridges stirs Galvin concern
Secretary of State William Galvin, who serves as chairman of the Massachusetts Historical Commission, said Harvard’s plans to expand the bridges and bury portions of Storrow Drive could run into trouble.
He noted that the Charles River’s basin is protected and that he’ll closely review Harvard’s plans. He said he’s worried that the plan could “adversely affect” the river.
“I’m very concerned,” said Galvin.
“If they’re treating the river like it’s their moat, I’ve got news for them: They don’t own the river.”
The Plan for Harvard in Allston
Harvard has unveiled a vision for its future, filing with the City of Boston a proposed Institutional Master Plan for the first stage of the physical evolution of an interdisciplinary campus in Allston.
Click here for the document (12 MB)
Why Charlesview matters to all of Allston (Harvard and the rest of us)
The possibility that a 550-person housing project at Charlesview might become a 1000-person housing project on Western Ave will have a huge impact on the future of the neighborhood. Here is what Harvard researchers wrote recently:
Of all the elements that determine a neighborhood’s quality of living, homes are by far the most influential. The types and condition of a neighborhood’s homes – whether houses or apartments, owned or rented – determine whether the residents will live in comfort and safety. The value or change in value of an area’s housing directly influences the financial condition of its occupants by providing more or less expensive shelter and, in the case of homeowners, increasing or decreasing the investment in the home.1
Experts at Harvard and elsewhere agree that we should strive to reduce or eliminate segregation based on race or income. In Boston and across the country, policies are being created to encourage a mix of incomes in housing developments and neighborhoods. Examples include the Federal Moving to Opportunity for Fair Housing (MTO) and HOPE VI programs. In this Harvard paper, researchers discuss the favorable results of the MTO program in Boston. Another Harvard paper addresses the complexities of housing policy and makes the case that mixed-income housing is not a "silver bullet".
What is clear is that thousands of new people will move to North Allston & North Brighton in the upcoming years and a new Charlesview development would be the first major housing development here in decades. It could significantly alter the demographics and appearance of the neighborhood. North Harvard Street could become a dividing line, with Harvard people isolating themselves to the east of the neighborhood in new enclaves.
Where the newcomers to our community will live and the type of housing that should be built are not simple questions. But they are very important ones. The housing goals in the North Allston Strategic Framework were a good start. Now we need Harvard, the City, the community, and others to begin serious planning to fulfill these goals before major development moves forward.
Harvard has the expertise to significantly contribute to a world-class housing plan for this community. Harvard claims to be interested in the success of Allston. Harvard says that housing policy is one of the most important factors in the success of a community. It is time for Harvard to follow up its talk about "partnerships" and "shared vision" with real action.
1 The Impact of Housing on Community: A Review of Scholarly Theories and Empirical Research Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard University - Alexander von Hoffman, Eric S. Belsky, and Kwan Lee - March 2006
State of the City press release and text
My favorite phrase from his speech is the emphasis on "the places that put life in city life."
It is that sentiment that leaves many of us so troubled when we look at the vacant Harvard-owned buildings in AB North. (Thanks to Tim McHale for creating that new phrase. It is so much easier to say and type than "North Allston and North Brighton"). It is the same lens through which we look at Harvard's new proposals, trying to see how they will put life into Western Ave, not just for Harvard affiliates but for everyone in the community.
Short list emerges for top job at Harvard
I think it is interesting that Harvard's Allston expansion is viewed as so important to Harvard that it may be shaping the selection of Harvard's next president.
State of the City speech tonight
Interview with Harvard-Allston Chief Chris Gordon
"The last thing you want to do is develop one-off projects every couple of
years and not understand the big picture. If you do it that way, you can’t look
at cumulative effects, like traffic, the impact on utilities, etc.""[The new IMP is] going to talk about the community – we want to work
with the community so there’s not a bright line between the community and the campus."""Everybody I meet with, from staff members up to the president, has said,
“You know, we’ll only do this once. We’re only going to build the campus once.
Let’s think about this.” People are watching what Harvard does to make sure we
do it right and that’s good."
Harvard IMP in downloadable pieces or a printed copy
Pages 1-50 (13MB)
Pages 51-100 (19MB)
Pages 101-125 (26MB)
Pages 126-282 (11MB)
Also, I have printed copies to distribute so you can call me at (617)538-7038 if you would like one.
Harvard Buys Vacant Tech Center
Harvard Crimson story about Harvard's purchase last month of 176 Lincoln St.
Harvard takes down fences
Want a printed copy of the Harvard Art Building Project Notification Form?
There are also a few people in the neighborhood who have been given copies to distribute to people in the community. I have 10 copies. First come - first served. Give me a call at (617)538-7038 if you'd like one.
- Harry
How Beacon Hill organized to stop Suffolk's dormitory plan
- A petition to the Mayor asking him to stop the approval process and require a comprehensive master plan from Suffolk before considering any new building
- A "call to action" flyer explaining how people can get involved
- A sample letter to help people submit feedback to the BRA
- The comment letter submitted by the Beacon Hill Civic Association
The Steppingstone Foundation
Deadline for applications for next year are February 1. Upcoming Family Information Meetings are being held on:
Tuesday, January 9, 2007: English High School, Jamaica Plain, 6:30 p.m.
Saturday, January 20, 2007: Boston College High School, Dorchester: 10:00 a.m.
Roll call vote on ballot question proposing gay marriage ban
Kevin G. Honan, D-Boston - N
Michael J. Moran, D-Boston - N
Jarrett T. Barrios, D-Cambridge - N
Steve A. Tolman, D-Boston - N
Property tax bills rising across state
The average tax bill on a single-family home in Boston will jump 12.3 percent to $3,093 in 2007. That's on top of a 9.6 percent jump between 2005 and 2006.
City Councilors pick Dorchester Councilor Maureen Feeney as president
Excerpt from Boston Globe story suggests power shift in City Council
Since 2002, the presidency -- and consequently powerful committee chairmanships -- lay in the hands of Flaherty and his supporters, a group of white men in their 20s and 30s. Now some of those councilors may have to take a back seat, along with their initiatives, to an emboldened minority caucus. They include Flaherty; Michael Ross of Beacon Hill, Back Bay and Mission Hill; Rob Consalvo of Hyde Park; and Jerry McDermott of Allston-Brighton .
Globe publishes letter in response to last week's Harvard-Allston story
YOU QUOTED Thomas Lentz, director of Harvard University Art Museums, describing my neighborhood as "Western Siberia" ("Harvard: New museum site is a better location, costs less," Style & Arts, Dec. 28).
True, we are a wasteland of Harvard's creation. For decades, using straw companies and individuals, Harvard has snapped up homes and businesses, having left them empty to decay so that their distressed abutters become new opportunities for acquisition. Real people lose their homes and jobs, but the institution prospers, and that's what they teach at the Business School.
My neighbors are not complainers. We desperately need to see Harvard succeed here and want only to be treated with respect and the honesty expected by a person in a Veritas tie.
If Mayor Menino wants a "legacy," as you so often write, he should seek it on the campus of Harvard and the streets of Allston. Far better than another ugly skyscraper with someone else's name, eternal honor will belong to the one who negotiates the success of the new Harvard Square.
Science museums struggle with how much of the present to include in their future
Boston Globe: Time warp - Science museums struggle with how much of the present to include in their future
Harvard's Museum of Natural History must leap forward from the 19th century. "The university museum has two major functions," said Dr. Steven E. Hyman, the provost of Harvard and a neuroscientist who has helped create exhibits for museums. "One is to support research, and the other is education." Unlike many science museums, Harvard has both a curatorial staff and affiliated researchers who use its collection of millions of zoological specimens.
That collection, founded by naturalist Louis Agassiz in 1859, includes stunning fossils and preserved animals, which help make it Harvard's leading paid attraction. But the cramped quarters leave little room for new science.
A move to Allston would add space but subtract historical significance. "The Museum of Natural History is also a museum of museums," noted Hyman. "It was the first collection to be displayed like that for public consumption."
The new Harvard report suggests that a move would help the museum's educational side, perhaps through a new "Museum of Evolution" combining different elements of the university's collection. "In the Allston era, we'll have an opportunity to invigorate the museum component of the university," said Stubbs.
Subscribe to AllstonBrighton2006 |
RSS Feed for this blog
Brighton Allston Improvement Association
Allston-Brighton bikes
Presentation School Foundation
Universal Hub
? Boston blog webring # >
By address |
Map of State Representative Districts |